Proof of Mailing vs Proof of Delivery: What You Actually Need for Compliance
By Lee Garvey
“I never received that notice.” Four words that can unravel months of careful compliance work, invalidate legal proceedings, or cost you thousands in litigation. The question isn’t whether you mailed something—it’s whether you can prove the recipient actually got it. That distinction determines whether you’re protected when disputes arise.
Understanding the difference between proof of mailing and proof of delivery isn’t legal nitpicking—it’s the line between being vulnerable and being protected. When you send mail online, you’ll choose between documentation levels with every mailing. Here’s what each type of proof actually establishes and when compliance requires which one.
Launch 500 postcards / flyers / letters in ~5 minutes. We print, address, and mail for you.
Upload your design and mailing list, pay, done.
No post office run. No subscriptions.
Next-business-day mailing for most products.
Proof of Mailing: What It Is and What It Proves
Proof of mailing documents that you sent something on a specific date through the postal system. It creates a timestamped record showing you fulfilled your obligation to send—proving the item left your control and entered the mail stream. This matters when your legal or compliance duty is to mail something, not necessarily to ensure receipt.
This proof typically includes the mailing date, your information as sender, recipient address, and confirmation that USPS accepted the item. With intelligent mail barcodes, you can track that your mailing entered the postal system and was processed. What you don’t get is confirmation of who received it or when it arrived at its destination.
Proof of mailing protects you in situations where your obligation ends with sending. If regulations require you to “mail a notice within 30 days,” proof of mailing shows you met that deadline. But it doesn’t protect you against claims that the recipient never got it—that requires different documentation.
Proof of Delivery: What It Is and What It Proves
Proof of delivery documents that a specific person received your mailing on a specific date, typically with signature confirmation. This creates evidence of actual receipt, not just that you sent something. It answers both “did I send it?” and “did they get it?”—providing complete documentation of the entire transaction.
This proof includes everything from proof of mailing plus delivery date, time, location, and often the signature of the person who accepted it. Some formats provide a physical return receipt (green card) that shows exactly who signed for the item. This level of detail makes the “I never received it” defense impossible to maintain credibly.
Proof of delivery protects you when receipt matters as much as sending. Legal notices, contract terminations, compliance notifications—these often require proving not just that you mailed something, but that the recipient actually got it. In disputes, proof of delivery is evidence that holds up in court and regulatory proceedings.
Key Differences: Why the Distinction Matters for Compliance
The distinction between these two types of proof isn’t academic—it determines whether you’re legally protected when disputes arise.
Legal Standing in Disputes
Proof of mailing shows you tried; proof of delivery shows they received. Courts and regulators treat these very differently in proceedings. The burden of proof shifts depending on which documentation you have. “I never got it” defeats proof of mailing but not proof of delivery, making this distinction critical in contested situations.
Compliance Requirements Vary by Regulation
Some regulations require only that you mail notices—proof of mailing is sufficient. Other regulations require confirmed receipt, making proof of delivery mandatory. Misunderstanding this distinction can invalidate your entire compliance effort. Industry-specific regulations often specify which proof is required, and choosing the wrong documentation level leaves you vulnerable.
Cost vs. Protection Trade-off
Proof of mailing costs standard postage rates. Proof of delivery requires Certified Mail with a $6.45-$11.04 premium. Choosing wrong means either wasting money or leaving yourself vulnerable. The right choice depends on your specific legal and regulatory requirements—not every mailing needs maximum documentation.
When Proof of Mailing Is Sufficient
Proof of mailing meets requirements in situations where your obligation is to send, not to ensure receipt.
Proof of mailing is sufficient when:
- Regulations require mailing by a deadline but don’t mandate confirmed receipt
- You’re creating internal records showing you attempted notification
- The relationship is ongoing and parties communicate regularly
- Good faith effort to notify is the legal standard
- Cost considerations outweigh the minimal risk of “never received” claims
- Municipality notifications where delivery confirmation isn’t legally required
- Marketing and promotional mailings focused on relationship-building
When Proof of Delivery Is Required
Proof of delivery becomes non-negotiable when receipt must be documented for legal protection or regulatory compliance.
Proof of delivery is required when:
- Sending legal notices where notification deadlines have legal consequences
- Employment terminations or disciplinary actions subject to labor law requirements
- Contract terminations where proper notification is contractually required
- Eviction notices and landlord-tenant legal communications
- Bankruptcy notifications and debt collection formal notices
- Compliance notifications in regulated industries (healthcare, finance, etc.)
- Any situation where “I never received it” could defeat your legal position
- Insurance claims requiring documented notification
How to Get Proof of Mailing
Multiple mailing methods provide proof that you sent something, with varying levels of documentation.
First-Class Mail with Intelligent Mail Barcode
First-Class Mail provides basic tracking showing your item entered the mail stream. You get confirmation of the mailing date and processing, creating an electronic record accessible online. This does NOT provide proof of delivery—only that you sent something. It’s sufficient for many routine business needs where proving receipt isn’t required.
Certificate of Mailing (USPS Form 3817)
This USPS receipt shows you mailed items on a specific date. It costs less than Certified Mail while providing official proof of mailing without delivery confirmation. It works well for situations requiring mailing deadline documentation when receipt confirmation isn’t necessary.
How to Get Proof of Delivery
Proof of delivery requires Certified Mail or similar services that document actual receipt with signature confirmation.
Certified Mail (Standard)
Certified Mail provides electronic proof of delivery with signature confirmation, starting from $6.45-$6.66 depending on format. You access delivery confirmation and signature online, creating an official USPS record admissible as evidence. This satisfies most legal and compliance requirements for proof of delivery.
Certified Mail with Return Receipt (Green Card)
This option provides a physical return receipt in addition to electronic proof, starting from $11.04. You get hardcopy documentation for your physical files, with the signature appearing on a card returned to you. Some legal proceedings prefer paper documentation, making this format necessary despite the higher cost.
The “I Never Received It” Defense: Which Proof Protects You
Proof of mailing leaves you vulnerable to the “I never received it” defense. You can prove you sent something, but the recipient can credibly claim it never arrived—lost in mail, wrong address, stolen from mailbox. Courts and regulators often accept this defense when only proof of mailing exists, especially if the recipient has no reason to lie about non-receipt.
Proof of delivery defeats the “I never received it” defense almost completely. When you have signature confirmation showing that John Smith signed for your notice on Tuesday at 2 PM, his claim that he never got it becomes legally untenable. The documentation proves not just sending but receipt, creating evidence that’s extremely difficult to refute in legal proceedings.
The protection difference is why Certified Mail exists despite the premium cost. In high-stakes situations—employment terminations, legal notices, contract disputes—the $6-11 cost of proof of delivery is insurance against claims that could cost thousands or tens of thousands in litigation. When you need to prove delivery, no cheaper alternative provides adequate protection.
Compliance Documentation: Retention and Access
Having the right proof matters only if you can access it when needed—months or years after the original mailing.
Documentation retention best practices:
- Electronic access: Online mailing services provide long-term access to mailing and delivery records
- Retention periods: Keep documentation as long as legal requirements specify (often 3-7 years)
- Audit readiness: Organize records so they’re retrievable for compliance audits or legal discovery
- Multiple formats: Maintain both electronic and physical records when regulations require it
- Quick retrieval: Index records so specific mailings can be found quickly during disputes
- Chain of custody: Maintain clear records of when mailings occurred for timeline-sensitive matters
Get the Right Proof for Your Compliance Requirements Today
You now understand exactly which documentation protects you legally—proof of mailing for routine notifications and proof of delivery when receipt must be documented. The stakes are too high to guess which level you need. Click2Mail makes it simple to choose the right option for every mailing, from First-Class with basic tracking to Certified Mail with complete delivery documentation. No subscription fees, no minimums, and next-day processing mean you can send compliance mailings with confidence whenever you need them.
Ready to send your next mailing with the proper documentation? Visit Click2Mail today to create your free account and access both proof of mailing and proof of delivery options. With cost estimation tools showing exactly what each documentation level costs, you can make informed decisions that balance legal protection with budget considerations. No post office trips, no confusing forms—just the right proof for your specific compliance requirements, accessible whenever audits or disputes arise.
About Lee
Lee Garvey is the founder of Click2Mail, a pioneering platform in cloud-based direct mail automation since 2003. Under his leadership, Click2Mail has become a trusted USPS partner, helping thousands of businesses streamline their mailing processes and effectively bridge the gap between digital and physical marketing.








